MILWAUKEE - The economic recovery plan passed by the U.S.
House on Wednesday earmarks about $2.4 billion for Wisconsin and
roughly half is designated as state budget aid. The other big chunk
-- $564 million -- is for highways and bridges.
The money is included in about $819 billion in spending
increases and tax cuts drafted by House Democrats and President
Barack Obama's economic team that are designed to -- in Wisconsin
Rep. Dave Obey's words -- "reinflate the economy." With House
approval, the plan goes to the Senate.
"The fact is that we need to compare the cost of this package
with the cost of doing nothing. The cost of doing nothing would be
catastrophic," said the Democratic chairman of the House
Appropriations Committee and one of the leading architects of the
legislation. "The cost of this package is well worth the risk
considering the alternative."
Obey, a congressman since 1969, said the country faces the most
dangerous economic situation in his lifetime as "consumer
purchasing power has evaporated."
"In most recessions, we're eventually led out of those
recessions through the leadership of the housing sector and the
automobile sector. This time around, both of those sectors are in
shambles, and they're not likely to lead anybody out of anything,"
Obey said. "So that leaves us with very limited tools."
The House bill provides tax cuts to put money in people's
pockets, creates jobs with infrastructure improvements, begins the
process of modernizing the economy, helps people most hurt by the
recession and save jobs by stabilizing state and local budgets,
Obey said.
Rep. Paul Ryan, R-Wis., said the bill actually exceeds $1
trillion in spending when interest on the debt is taken into
account and it won't help the economy.
"We can do better than this," he said, calling the package a
"spending wish list" for special interest groups. He said half of
the spending doesn't occur for two years and the tax cuts for a
single worker amount to $10 a week.
"After we go on this spending binge, this will lead to higher
taxes," Ryan said. "Higher taxes on small businesses. Higher
taxes on capital. Higher taxes on investments, on our savings
portfolios, on our retirements, on our college savings plans. That
is what is in store right around the corner at the end of next
year."
Rep. James Sensenbrenner, R-Wis., said he opposed the bill
because it would neither create jobs nor stimulate the economy.
Wisconsin Environment, an advocacy group for clean air, clean
water and open space, said the bill would benefit Wisconsin with
"bold investments" in clean energy and energy efficiency. It
includes nearly $12 billion for public transit and clean
transportation, director Dan Kohler said.
Wisconsin would receive nearly $73 million for mass transit.
WISPIRG, a public interest advocacy group in Madison, said the
House bill could be improved by assigning priority to highway and
bridge repairs instead of new construction, and by including more
money for expanding public transit.